Transcript
Brett McKay:
Brett McKay here and welcome to another edition of the Art of Manliness Podcast. So earlier this year, we published an in-depth series about masculinity in the Christian religion. In particular, why it is that nearly all Christian churches the world over, women outnumber men. And one of the sources for that series was a book called Why Men Hate Going to Church. And today on the show, I talk with the author of that book, David Murrow. David and I talked about the significant disparity in the sex ratio of Christian churches, the factors that led to that gender gap, why fewer men in the pews typically leads to an overall decline in congregation attendance, what some churches are doing to make the church more man-friendly and why newer megachurches have been more successful at attracting men than older mainline churches and why one branch of Christianity, Eastern orthodoxy, hasn’t suffered the same decline in male attendance that’s plagued other traditional denominations.
Whether you enjoyed our series on Christianity and manhood, have wondered why you find going to church so unbearable or simply enjoy discussions on the intersection of faith, culture and masculinity, you’re going to love this podcast. After the show’s over, check out the show notes at aom.is/murrow.
David Murrow, welcome to the show.
David Murrow:
Thanks Brett. Good to be with you.
Brett McKay:
So you wrote a book called Why Men Hate Going to Church, and we used it as a source on a series about Christianity and manhood about a month ago and sort of the muscular Christianity movement that happened in the late 19th and early 20th century. And I want to get you on the show to discuss more about the research you’ve done about men in the Christian church today. So your book’s called Why Men Hate Going to Church. So the underlying assumption is that men don’t really go to church. So start off, can you give us a big picture view of the engagement of men within Christian churches and what does the ratio of men to women look like in most congregations?
David Murrow:
Well, the average church in North America draws an adult crowd that’s 61% female and 39% male. That’s sort of the average. There are certain subsets of Christianity where the ratio might be three to one, four to one. African American churches tend to be very heavily female. And then overseas, I get emails from pastors all the time who are asking me, how do I get any men involved in my church? We had a leadership conference in Nicaragua and 90% of the leaders who showed up were women. So there’s definitely a disengagement among men from institutional religion in the West and in Christianity in particular.
Brett McKay:
And I mean, I think many people, the common explanation for this is that, well, the gender gap exists because women are just more inherently spirituallyl religious across the board. Does this gender gap exist in all religions then?
David Murrow:
Well, the statement you made is slightly true. There was a Pew study that came out in early 2016 that confirmed that women are slightly more spiritual in their attitudes, but when it comes to religious practice, in most religions, women and men have roughly equal participation. The two outliers are Islam where men are much more involved in participating in religion than women, and then Christianity where women are way more involved than men. So Christianity is really the only major world religion that has the size of gender gap that we see. All the other religions are either slightly more male or quite closely balanced with a slight preference with females.
Brett McKay:
So I mean, when did this disparity begin? Because I think a lot of people say, “Well, this is just a recent phenomenon.” Is this a long term problem that Christianity has had? When did this disparity between men and women in the pew start?
David Murrow:
Well, according to a Catholic scholar by the name of Lee Podles, the disparity really began shortly after the Eastern Church and the Western Catholic Church separated around the year 12, 1300. It’s when a period of bridal mysticism kind of took over the monasteries, the Catholic monasteries during the Middle Ages. And we began to see the withdrawal of men from churches. Men took a more passive role. They weren’t even allowed to go up and accept communion, had to be put on their tongues. There was really only work for the priests and the laymen had nothing to do. With the reformation, the Protestant reformation, we saw a fresh awakening among men. We saw much higher male participation in religion around the colonial times. But then in the Victorian era, we began to see men withdrawing from the church again. Men left homes to find work in mines, mills, and factories.
And the people left behind were women, children, and aged men too old to work in the mines. And that has been the predominant demographic in the Western church for 200 years. There are lots of women, lots of children, lots of aged men, older men, but the young viral man, the working man, the blue collar man has been conspicuously absent with the sole exception being the 1950s. After World War II, we saw the joiner builder generation came back to church in force. The church grew. It set the stage for the growth of the megachurch and some of the phenomena we see today. But if you’re asking about the long-term trends, yes, Christianity has always had a gender gap and revivals and awakenings have brought men back for a little while, but then the churches tend to re-feminize over time.
Brett McKay:
What was it about bridal mysticism that turned men off back in the 1200s?
David Murrow:
Oh, there was lots of talk about Jesus suckling at his breast, a lot of imagining him as female. It was a very cultish time in the church. The monasteries, there was a lot of homosexuality in the monasteries and the straight guy of the year 1300, there really wasn’t much for him to do in the church. The clergy definitely professionalized, evangelism and church growth was de-emphasized and with this very institutional structure that was controlled by eggheads and there just wasn’t much for the layman to do. And so we see a withdrawal of men and a pouring of more feminine sentiments out of the church.
Brett McKay:
Right. And you still see those sentiments today and you talk about, we’ll talk about this later, but praise and worship music, Jesus is a lover that you’re supposed to embrace.
David Murrow:
Well, that’s driven more by market forces. Women buy about 75% of the Christian music. A lot of these women are either single or they’re trapped in loveless marriages. So the image of Jesus as a lover, a protector, someone who’s right there by your side, a comforter, these images are very comforting to women who do not experience the love of a man in their daily life. Jesus kind of is portrayed as this cryptic sort of substitute lover for the man you don’t have. And so the reason we see so much feminine imagery in praise and worship today is because that’s who buys the CDs, that’s who downloads the songs, are these women who are looking for love.
Brett McKay:
Right. I guess I can see why that would turn guys off. You guys don’t want Jesus as a boyfriend. But what are men looking for in a God to worship? I mean, it seems like women are more relational. What is it that men are looking for and aren’t getting?
David Murrow:
Well, the United States just elected a strong man president and with heavy, heavy support from men. And I think that’s a window into the type of leader that men are looking for. We tend to gravitate toward a leader who is leading us onto the battlefield rather than into the bedroom. And a lot of the sentiment and praise and worship today definitely feels like Jesus is our lover rather than our leader. So we used to have very militant battle oriented hymns, the battle hymn of the republic or a mighty fortress is our God or onward Christian soldiers. And what’s interesting is in the most feminized denominations, the more liberal mainline denominations, we see those songs have been banned. They’re politically incorrect. You can’t sing a song with any battle imagery in it because it’s considered warlike and too violent. And so this maternalism in these churches is definitely driving men away because there’s just nothing to interest them.
Brett McKay:
Well, what’s interesting, Christianity was founded by a man and he had 12 of his male comrades helping him out. And much of the leadership in most Christian churches remains male. So I mean, it is odd that more women than men are attending. And often Christianity gets criticized as being patriarchal, but at the same time there’s more women attending. So we’ve talked about some of the historical factors, but what are some of the other factors, sort of micro factors that are influencing male attendance and engagement in Christian churches?
David Murrow:
Well, let me clarify a comment that you just made. You had said that there’s a perception that churches are male dominated. If you’re talking about that relatively thin stratum of paid professional clergy, then yes, by all means, churches are male dominated. But really, when you get beyond that stratum, if you talk about people who volunteer in church, people who work on the church payroll, people who run the ministries, overwhelmingly female, about 75% of paid Christian workers are women. That’s talking about the church secretary, missionary, support personnel, et cetera. And they bring their feminine sensibilities to their ministries. We had a balance in the church for hundreds of years. The clergy and the elders, the ruling elders of a church were all men, but the lay leaders in the church were women. And so you had a strong masculine sensibility directionally with the church from the pulpit and from the decision making process.
But then the day-to-day ministries had the characteristic feminine relational feel to it. You had a yin and a yang, you had a masculine and a feminine, you had a lion and a lamb. Today, especially in those mainline churches, as men have withdrawn from the formal leadership posts and women have taken those over, there’s no countervailing masculine spirit in those churches. Everything is about nurture. Everything is about relationships. Everything is about, it’s not about doctrine anymore or great truths. It’s about how can we comfort these oppressed people? And although that would resonate with some men, a lot of men simply see that as weakness and they choose to withdraw.
Brett McKay:
And I mean, so that kind of goes to one of the points you made, that one reason that men say they don’t go to church is that it’s too safe. There’s no risk taking or innovation going on. A lot of meetings talking about relationships and they feel like the meetings are unproductive. In what other ways do churches squander a man’s general tendency? Again, we’re talking generalities here for innovation and risk taking.
David Murrow:
Well, maybe I could answer your question this way. We find that church plants have no problem attracting men, a church plant being a new church that’s founded in a new area of town or a new building. Usually those tend to be fifty fifty. And I think the reason why is because a man’s natural gifting is very valued in a church plant. First of all, there’s a heavy pressure to bring new people in, evangelism, confronting people with the truths of the Bible. You have to get out there or the church is going to close its doors. Strategic planning, strategizing, these sorts of things that men love to play Stratego and war games and from the time they’re children. Strategy is definitely a very, tends to be a more masculine trait. Men love to strategize. You got to build a building. You got to buy a building. You got to remodel a building. You got to paint the building. You got to do the things that men tend to do.
Once a church institutionalizes, once the building is bought, once the programs are running, now the masculine gifts that were so valuable during the planting phase become liabilities. What you need at that point is a steady, gentle ministry that keeps the children happy, that keeps the women volunteering, that keeps the building maintained, and the number of things for men to do declines rapidly. So what we’re seeing is young churches do very well attracting men, but over time the men become disinterested and disengaged because their natural gifting is not only seen as unnecessary, but it’s often seen as harmful because when you’re talking about disruptive change and culture change and these sorts of things upset people, and that is antithetical to a maintenance mode, which is where most churches are today.
Brett McKay:
Particularly you talk about the book Mainline Protestant Churches that are struggling the most because they’re established, they’ve been around for decades, centuries. But on the other hand, these mega churches that are popping up, these are the ones that are really doing well with men and also just they’re doing better than the mainline Protestant churches.
David Murrow:
Well, the main line is fighting a lot of headwinds. A, it’s the feminization, the withdrawal of men. B, the way they’re administered. Their administrative structures were created in the 17 and 1800s when there was no internet, there was no telephone. And the biggest problem then was heresy. You had to control individual congregations out on the prairie to keep some pastor from going off and preaching that Jesus was a unicorn or some crazy nutty thing like that. So what they did is they created all these committees and subcommittees and levels of control. Every Presbyterian church is under the governance of a session, a presbytery, a synod, and a general assembly, four levels of control on every congregation. So what that leads to is a very slow deliberative decision process, drives men up the wall. Men are used to the fields of business, sports, these sorts of places where they predominate, where decisions are made quickly, where people’s feelings get hurt and we move on.
In churches, it doesn’t work that way because there are so many levels of control and so many ways that innovation can be stopped in order to preserve relationships. The men who lead in church get extremely frustrated because things move so slowly and every decision is looked at through the lens of who is this going to hurt and how do we keep people happy and nurtured and these sorts of things. So the main line is really struggling with a culture that was built for an agrarian age and with a governance structure that really, really frustrates men.
Brett McKay:
So going back to the megachurch thing, so the megachurch does have a very business ethos. You walk into one, there’s mission statements everywhere. You can take courses on leadership, they have courses on finances, and then you get a very dynamic lesson or sermon from a very dynamic minister. But you also talk about in the book, one of the things that might appeal to men that megachurches do is that they separate their vertical and horizontal worship. Can you describe what that means and why you think smaller churches stumble by trying to combine the two together?
David Murrow:
Well, yeah, let me set that up by saying that the megachurches, all the disadvantages we talked about the mainline, the megachurches have dispensed with those. They tend to be a very short… First of all, there’s no denominational structure over most of them. Decisions are made all on the local level. They’re usually led by a CEO type person who really could have made an impression in the business world, usually more aggressive, a good communicator, good looking, good baritone voice, great communicator. That type of guy is almost always at the head of a megachurch. You don’t have Casper Milk Toast as the pastor of the local megachurch. It’s always a guy with some charisma, and he has a very free hand to move quickly and to adapt and innovate when opportunities or problems arise in the church as they inevitably do. That’s one of the reasons megachurches are just killing the traditional churches because their governance structure and the people that they have in charge.
Now back to answer your question though, restate it again. I lost it a little bit.
Brett McKay:
It was about vertical and horizontal worship.
David Murrow:
So then in the actual worship services, the megachurches are very, very aware of men’s needs. The two most famous mega churches in the 1980s and 90s are Willow Creek and Saddleback. And both of those churches were founded by very charismatic men who recognized that if a guy would come to church, they would get the family in the deal. So what’s interesting is Bill Hybels, the founder of Willow Creek, started off his church with a mythical parishioner called Unchurched Harry, and he built the entire church around that man’s sensibilities and needs. He created a church that man would come to and feel comfortable enough to stay near the gospel. Brooke Warren did the exact same thing five years later in Southern California. He had a mythical parishioner called Saddleback Sam. Again, neither of these megachurch innovators targeted women at all. That’s not to say they didn’t care about women, but they realized that men were the first domino that had to fall.
If you got the man, you got the family and the deal. And so they built their church around men, the way the church is decorated. You won’t see a lace doily, you’re not going to see a flower or a ribbon. You’re not going to see these school style construction paper bulletin boards that you often see in family churches. They dispensed with all the frufu and childlike decor and they made their churches gender neutral. And then they separated the horizontal worship from the vertical worship. And what I mean by that is if you go to a small traditional church, you’ll often have people stand up and share prayer requests or the church at some point during the worship service, the church will kind of devolve into a very large support group, 80 people standing up, sharing their prayers and praises, definitely family oriented, horizontally focused on one another.
If you go to a megachurch, it’s impossible for 3,000 people to share prayer needs on Sunday morning. So what the brilliance of the megachurch model is you focus exclusively vertically on Sunday morning. It’s all upward toward God. There’s very little interaction among the congregation. However, these churches realize you need a horizontal component to faith practice as well. So they push small groups relentlessly. Every week you go to a mega church, you will be invited, hectored, bothered. They are going to get after you about being in a small group because they realize Sunday morning is completely vertical. That’s the way it has to be in such a large congregation, but they realize that people need horizontal fellowship as well. They have to have human touch, and that’s true for men and women. So they push these small groups relentlessly and their model is working very well.
Now they have a worship service on Sunday morning that is focused upward toward God, which men appreciate. They don’t necessarily want a support group on Sunday morning. And then they have a vehicle of midweek small groups, which allows men to let their hair down a little bit more, be a little more intimate and real with one another, get to know people on a closer basis. And this model seems to be working very, very well in the megachurches these days.
Brett McKay:
Well, in going back, so in the worship service, it’s presented by a very dynamic pastor. I’m from Oklahoma, Life Church is huge.
David Murrow:
Craig Groeschel.
Brett McKay:
Yeah. Craig Groeschel. And I’ve been to it. I go every now and then and the guy is like, he’s impressive. He’s charismatic, dynamic. He’s buff. He works out and he talks about working out. So I can see how a lot of men are drawn to that, right? But then whenever the music comes on, you don’t see a lot of guys singing the songs because they’re still doing sort of the praise and worship kind of romance stuff.
David Murrow:
Yes, they are. Although things are getting better. I think our ministry, Church for Men, was really the first one to get out there and call worship leaders out on this issue and heard from quite a few. And we’ve kind of started a quiet revolution in worship music to reconnect the militant side of our faith to our music. And we are slowly seeing the love songs to Jesus get put on the shelf and we’re seeing more songs about God’s majesty, his power, his ability to do miracles. We’re actually even seeing some mild battle imagery coming back into some of the songs. And the other thing that used to drive men crazy was what was called the 7-Eleven song. You sang seven words 11 times and it just repeated over and over again and you’d slowly work your way into a worship coma. That is starting to go away.
But the big challenge for men is familiarity. One thing that I’m sure you understand about men is if we feel incompetent to something, we simply don’t do it. We stop doing it. And one of the big challenges with praise and worship today is that we’ve abandoned the hymnal in favor of the big screen in the front, the projection screen. When we had a hymnal, we had a canon of about 250 songs that everybody knew. We knew how to sing them. We could sing them without the notes on the page. We basically knew the lyrics, Amazing Grace and these sorts of songs. We all knew them. When the computer control projection screen came into the sanctuary about 20 years ago, we went from 200 songs everybody knows to 200,000 songs nobody knows. I mean, you can put anything on that screen. And so what we’re seeing is worship leaders around the country are putting unknown songs up every week in an effort to be cool and hip.
And so the congregation doesn’t sing these songs and men in particular don’t because they don’t know the lyrics, they don’t know the tune. It’s probably keyed too high because the worship leader’s a high tenor and he’s up there doing a private rock show for us while the men stand there with their hands in their pockets thinking, “I wish this was over. Let’s get to the sermon.” So we’re seeing a real participation gap in the church, not only among men, but women as well because worship is becoming such a performance driven thing. We’ve almost returned to medieval Catholicism, which was a time when the laity was not even allowed. They were prohibited from participating in the worship service. They had to stand mute while professional canters performed at the altar. And we’re kind of returning to that now with this professionalizing of worship. We say, “Hey, everybody stand up and sing,” but nobody’s doing it and it’s becoming a real issue with men.
Brett McKay:
Right. No one knows the word. So innovate, but not too much. Don’t innovate with the music.
David Murrow:
Well, one of the things that I really appreciate about my church here in Anchorage is our worship leader always includes a couple of old hymns and the young people really like the hymns. They’re looking for something a little more rooted, a little more pithy. Who cares if we can’t understand a few of the words or there might be a couple of archaic phrases or these or thous. What it does is it gives us a sense of majesty and grandeur of God rather than songs that solely talk about how my emotions are, “Oh God, I love you so much. You’re so beautiful.” A lot of these songs with their very romantic lyrics or emotion laden lyrics really just don’t connect to the masculine heart. Men are really more about the mission. Women are more about the relationship. And so our music has to reflect that.
Brett McKay:
So I think you alluded to this a bit, but I mean, why is it important for congregations to have more men in the pews? I mean, can’t they get along without them?
David Murrow:
Well, what we’re finding is that the congregations with the largest gender gaps tend to be the ones that are growing the slowest or actually in decline. The biggest gender gap to domination we have right now in the United States is the Episcopal church, which lost 23% of its members in the last decade. The Episcopal church will, if current trends continue, the Episcopal church in the USA will cease to exist by about the year 2060. So the gender gap goes hand in hand with church decline. Meanwhile, if we look at the profile of growing churches, we tend to see near gender parity. Men bring a certain vitality. A wise Texas preacher once told me that when the woman comes, you get the tithe off the grocery money. When the man comes, you get the tithe off the paycheck. So men tend to bring money with them.
They bring resources that women often don’t possess. And just from a perspective of boys growing up in the church, they love to see their fathers involved. If dad is not involved, boys tend to drop out of the church in much higher numbers. So if you want a healthy church that attracts all kinds of people, you have to work very hard to attract and engage the men.
Brett McKay:
And what do men stand to benefit from going to church regularly? I mean, a lot of guys it’s a waste of time, but there are some benefits to it, right?
David Murrow:
Oh, the benefits are huge. Study after study has shown a very positive correlation between mental health and church attendance. And this is true in both men and women across the globe. Also, a very exhaustive study from the Heritage Foundation found a very strong correlation between church attendance and the avoidance of many social pathologies, drug use, drunkenness, violence, incarceration. Men who go to church are something like four and five times less likely to engage in these behaviors than men who avoid it. One other study that came out of the University of Chicago a few years ago was entitled Soft Patriarchs. It studied the familial ties of irreligious men, religious men, Catholic men, Protestant men, et cetera. And it found that evangelical Protestant men were far and away the best fathers and husbands as pulled by their wives and by their children and by their habits. Again, much less likely to drink to excess, much more likely to provide for their families.
There’s just a very, very strong correlation between church involvement and a host of good outcomes for men and for society.
Brett McKay:
So what can congregations do to make church more male friendly? Because not every church is going to be a mega church. I mean, is it a matter of… I mean, I’ve seen some churches do these things like when it’s Super Bowl Sunday, they’ll have Super Bowl Sunday sermon or like Harley Sunday where you can wear your… Is it doing that or is that too superficial? Does it need to be something more rooted?
David Murrow:
Well, let me start by saying that we tend to welcome… We see as normal things that are female oriented, whereas we tend to see things that are male oriented in the church as pandering or superficial. I’ll give you an example. If a church were to announce a women’s scrapbooking night or a women’s quilting night or whatever, we wouldn’t bat an eye. We wouldn’t think twice. We would see that as a perfectly appropriate recreational activity for the women of the church. Now, if we had a men’s cigar night, I can tell you most churches would be up in arms. Now, neither smoking nor quilting is mentioned in the Bible. However, we tend to see the masculine activity as unChristlike, whereas the feminine one is very Christlike. Going back to quilts, if we decorated our church with quilts, we say, “Oh, that’s normal.” I mean, probably half the churches in America have a quilt hanging somewhere.
We see that as normal church decor. If a church were to take down the quilts and put up mounted animal heads like a hunter would bring from the hunt, there would be tons of opposition to that. Now, again, how many quilts are there in the Bible? Zero. How many dead animals are there? There’s a dead animal on practically every page of the Old Testament. But we tend to react negatively to anything that sort of appeals to masculine sensibilities, whereas we see those things that appeal to feminine sensibilities as perfectly normal and acceptable. So now back to your original question, do we need to have a men’s truck night or whatever, however you phrased it, a Harley night or a Harley event or a car show or whatever. I’m all about those things. If you’ll attract men with those things, that’s fine, but it’s really not about painting a macho veneer on a feminized church.
What you have to do is you’ve got to look down at the way you’re governed. You have to look at the way the church is decorated. You have to look at the way you’re presenting the gospel. Are you speaking of it as a passionate, intimate relationship with a man who loves you? Or are you talking about it as a dangerous mission? The metaphors the pastor uses, the type of things the pastor speaks of from the pulpit. You mentioned Craig Gochelle’s very good about talking about working out, about the adventures he goes on. Men love to hear, men love to have a pastor they can relate to as a man. And so he’s very intentional about talking about guy stuff from the pulpit. Many pastors are not. So there’s just a host of things and on my website, churchformen.com, I’ve got a lot of resources for churches that want to start to begin this process of making the church a more welcoming space to men and boys.
And I’ve also got 60 pages in my book, but that’s just a few of them. And the nice thing, like you said, you don’t have to be a mega church to attract men. Any congregation, a congregation of 50 people can start to do little things that will attract more men, and these things do work.
Brett McKay:
So throughout, particularly in America, there have been these movements to proactively go after men. And we talked about in our series a month ago about the muscular Christianity movement. For those who aren’t familiar, can you talk a little bit about what the muscular Christianity movement was about and was it even successful?
David Murrow:
My feeling is it was very successful. Muscular Christianity was a reaction to industrialization. You have to understand that the entire world was agrarian and organic before 1800. And then with the invention of the steam engine and the rise of machines, in the 1850s and 60s, we began to see a retreat of men from physical labor As machines began to take over more of the labor. And there was a real panic in our country about men being inside all the time, bookish men, the traditional masculine virtues that had opened up the frontier were being forgotten and lost. And that situation was particularly acute in the church because as I alluded to earlier, during the Victorian era, men began to withdraw from the church in huge numbers. Pastors got the reputation as being bookish, sickly, girly type men. And so there was this movement called the Muscular Christianity Movement, which attempted to return or restore a healthy masculinity to the church to make the church welcoming to men once again.
And probably the crown jewel of that movement was the Young Men’s Christian Association or YMCA as we know it. And they took the radical steps of bringing gymnasiums into churches. And at the time, this was considered extremely controversial. The whole idea that exercise and physicality somehow could be linked to faith, that was completely beyond the pale. Coming as we did from a Puritan and congregationalist and tradition where the body was suspect, the whole idea that bodybuilding could be a part of our Christian faith was completely beyond the pale. And then another movement was the Christian camp movement. The first Christian camp was founded in the 1880s as a way of getting young boys who had been civilized and sissified in the cities out into the country, getting them doing guy stuff out in the country. In 1905, a fellow in England founded the Boy Scouts and there was the Boys Brigade, Christian Service Brigade.
Some of those are still with us today. And these were organizations that were designed to get these sissified boys out into the country and introduce them to Christ through in this more masculine milieu than they were getting in their city life with their mothers. And in 1912, sort of the peak of the mescular Christianity movement was the Men in Religion Forward Movement, was a short-lived about a year, but it was a series of revival meetings all around the country. Billy Sunday was among the speakers. And it was kind of a prototype, a forerunner to the Promise Keepers Movement, large gatherings of men in different cities, listening to speakers, singing robust and roaring songs of the church and revival, actually a small revival broke out in many of these cities as men came to accept Christ and religion. The World Wars of World War I and World War II really kind of put church growth on hold.
We began to see men going off to war. Women stayed home and kept the hearth and the church going. But then when we saw the return of men from World War II, we saw a robust return to the church. And guess what? The churches that men found acceptable to return to were the mainline churches, Presbyterian, Methodist, Lutheran, et cetera. My own father defected from his Catholicism and became a Lutheran during that time. And the reason men found these mainline Protestant churches so attractive is because they had been the exponents of muscular Christianity. It was the Presbyterians that started church gyms. It was the Methodists who were doing YMCA and Boy Scouts. These mainline churches that we see as so feminized today were actually the largest proponents of muscular Christianity, this linking of manhood and Christianity. So back to your original question, was the muscular Christianity movement ultimately successful?
I believe it was. I believe it was responsible for the huge growth in the mainline church in post-World War II America, but when the mainline churches began turning away from masculine values toward anti-war activism, feminism, gay rights, this constellation of more female issues, we began to see the withdrawal of men and the implosion of those churches.
Brett McKay:
So yeah, there’s that feminization cycle that you talk about. Things start off robust and then as things get established, it becomes more feminized or more nurturing.
David Murrow:
Yeah. It’s more about in the early stages of a church, it’s more about it’s a blazing the trail, it’s pioneering, it’s more risky. Once the institutional structure’s in place, the building is built, the paint is up, the carpet’s down, really what is there for a man to do? All you have to do at that point is maintain the institution. And if you bring those trailblazing values into an established church, you just upset people. You start overturning the fundraising table in the Narthex. So it’s definitely a battle for an established church to maintain a connection with men. And the way that mega churches have done that is through just continually sponsoring these big initiatives. Rick Warren, 15 years ago, had this peace initiative in Rwanda and he sent hundreds of his people over there to Africa to try to restore that country. And they’ve done tremendous yeoman’s work over there in reestablishing an economy in Rwanda and bringing reconciliation between the Hutus and the Tutsis.
People don’t know it, but it’s his church, Saddleback Church that has been at the epicenter of those reconciliation efforts. And so Rick Warren has got this big story he tells every Sunday about what they’re doing, this dangerous work they’re doing all over the world. And men say, “Hey, here’s a church that’s doing something dangerous. We’re not just caring for the sick locally, we are changing the world globally.” And that sort of big picture tends to attract and retain men.
Brett McKay:
Yeah. And I’ve noticed too, the new abolitionist movement with the sex trade, a lot of churches are using that. These guys are going in doing investigations with… And it is kind of dangerous. They’re having to do undercover work to bust these sex ring operations in other countries.
David Murrow:
Tremendously helpful because as you know, every man has a natural, an inborn or trained instinct to protect the women around him. It’s one of the core aspects of masculinity is protect the women. It’s one of the first things we learn when we’re little boys, protect the women. So as churches have embraced this ministry to hurting women around the world, men have stepped up and done a tremendously courageous work in response to the needs of these women.
Brett McKay:
And can you talk a little bit about the Promise Keepers Movement? I I remember a kid back in the 90s, you would see these things on the news all the time. They’re filling giant sports arenas, stadiums, tens of thousands of men were going to these things. And then nowadays they can barely fill a venue. So what was it about the Promise Keepers movement that resonated with men for a moment, but no longer is as effective?
David Murrow:
Well, like anything, there’s a tendency for the new to be exciting. If you’ve been to a Promise Keepers rally, the first one I went to was in Seattle in 1996, flew down from Anchorage. It was the nearest one. Flew down from Anchorage with my father-in-law and a good friend of his and we attended and I was absolutely amazed. I had been a Christian at that point for 20 years and I had never worshiped in the presence of so many men. Every time I had ever been in a worship service, there was always more women than men. The women participated more enthusiastically than the men. But going to a Promise Keepers rally was absolutely transformational for me and actually planted the seeds for my book because I began asking the question, why is Promise Keepers so different than my local church? Why are men so enthusiastic in this stadium and so passive back in the church?
But like any movement, it has its heyday, it has its peak, and then people have done it and it’s been there, done that. Promise Keepers also came of age right before the internet really took off. And so I predicted it’s probably the last mass movement of men that we’re going to see, the last mass gathering of men that we’re going to see because men are gathering in virtual tribes now, online tribes, and it’s very, very hard to get men to gather. Men can get great Bible teaching now just by clicking on their smartphones or their computers. They can hear preachers who are way better than the guy down the street. And men are reinventing the church around non-traditional structures. And although that works well for the tech savvy, we’re seeing a lot of men who are simply giving up on the church. So back to your original question though, why was Promise Keepers so big?
It was a fresh movement. Men had been ignored in the church for quite a long time. It was something new and exciting and quite exhilarating. The speakers were quite good. The music was great and it was just great to be with that many men. But I fear that that may be the last large gathering of men ever because technology is making gathering less and less attractive to men.
Brett McKay:
Well, going on that line, I mean it seems like men are using technology to innovate. They’re having virtual… You can watch Life Church, you can watch Life Church from your laptop if you wanted to. And I can see the benefit, right? You’re getting something, but I mean it seems like you’re missing out on something when you don’t have that face-to-face meet space interaction.
David Murrow:
Absolutely. Yeah. I mean, just watching sermons on a screen is not going to get it done, but there are virtual gathering spaces where men actually interact and those are quite positive. I know there are groups of military men who continue to meet with their home group. They’ll be deployed to Afghanistan or Baghdad or Iraq or something or Africa, and they continue to meet with their men’s group back in Houston or Columbus, Ohio or wherever that was by means of technology. So yeah, just sitting down and watching a sermon isolates, but technology can also draw men together and that’s been one of the more positive things that technology has done.
Brett McKay:
Yeah. One group I’ve seen online that has been having success getting men together in real life is the F3, I think is what they’re called, Faith Family Fellowship. And basically they have these workouts in the morning. It’s like a bootcamp style workout and they end with a prayer or something like that. Guy’s last name’s Don. I’ve been wanting to get him on the podcast for a while, but that’s kind of an interesting… They’re kind of combining the two. It’s not centralized. It’s just you can start one up and they use the internet to facilitate. Sort of like CrossFit. There’s no real central organization there. It’s very networked, just kind of nice.
David Murrow:
Yes, very much so. But you’re right. If you don’t regularly connect with other guys, that’s really the secret sauce of the church and it has been for 2000 years, is not really what happens from the chancel, from the pulpit. It’s really what happens in the pews among the men. If you have strong fellowship and a strong honeycomb of relationships in the church, the men, you won’t be able to pry men out of the church. You won’t be able to blast them out with dynamite. But if the men don’t know each other and they just kind of go and sing the songs and listen to the sermon and drop their 20 in the plate, that’s not a recipe for success. And to their credit, most churches are working very hard to get people beyond that model of just sit passively watching. But a lot of the trends in the church today are militating against that.
Brett McKay:
So when we wrote our series about Christianity’s manhood problem, we had lots and lots of readers chime in who were Eastern Orthodox and they said, “Hey, wait minute. You need to check out the Eastern Orthodox Church. We don’t have that problem.” Why is that? I mean, it seems like men are doing well within the Eastern Orthodox Church. You mentioned way back at the beginning of the podcast when the problem in the Western church began when there was the schism between the Eastern and the Western. So what’s the Eastern Orthodox Church doing differently than Western churches that have been able to maintain a more parody amongst the sexes and the pews?
David Murrow:
Well, I mean, you’re right. The Eastern church never did feminize. There was never the bridal mysticism and the monastic problems of the 12 and the 1300s. And they’ve always allowed married priests, which has cut down on the incidence of homosexuality among their leaders. So there hasn’t been this wall between the priesthood and laity that there was during Catholicism that Pope Francis is working very hard to break that wall down, but it’s still there. So back to the Eastern Orthodox though, there have been significant pockets of that religion here in America. I’ve attended some Eastern Orthodox worship services. They’re very long. They’re very rigorous. They often take two hours or more. You stand most of the time. There are chairs and you’re allowed to sit only during the homily, which is usually just a short part of the service.
There’s incense and candles and bells and it’s just very ancient feeling. So it’s a rigorous type of worship. But I would say Eastern Orthodoxy, as strong as it is with men, is not really catching fire with men. We’re not seeing a huge growth evangelistically. We’re not seeing a lot of men converting to Eastern Orthodox doxy. I’m not sure that’s a model that a lot of modern men are going to go for, but I think within their structures and within their priesthood and the way they operate, there are the seeds of lots of good ideas. It’s only going to attract a man who’s looking for a very ancient and traditional form of worship. In our modern society, that population of men is relatively small.
Brett McKay:
I also think beards. They have awesome beards. I think that’s the secret too.
David Murrow:
Well, but you know what? I mean, go to any church planters conference and you’re going to see some really righteous facial hair. You know what I’m saying?
Brett McKay:
No, my favorite… There’s a Eastern Orthodox priest that reads the site and he sent us a picture of him. He’s like this older guy had this awesome gray beard and he had this giant kettlebell. It’s the coolest picture. I’ll have to post it on the show notes for you guys to see it. It’s a great, great picture showcasing the masculine vitality of the Eastern Orthodox Church. Well, Dave, this has been a great conversation. Where can people learn more about your book and your work?
David Murrow:
I have a website, churchformen.com. I’m also on the board of the National Coalition of Ministries for Men, which is ncmm.org. If you want to learn more about the full constellation of what’s going on in men’s ministry, I’d highly recommend that you go visit NCMM. We’re over 200 organizations and individuals who are pushing the men’s ministry movement forward in the church. There are a growing number of resources out there that are designed to help churches become more welcoming and friendly to men. My theory has always been this, is I’m not out there to call men back to the church. I’m here to call churches back to men. It’s interesting, just the smallest things that your church does to make it more welcoming to men will pay huge dividends down the road. In my book, I tell the story of a pastor’s conference. Every spring I do this pastor’s conference down in Illinois, and one time I was speaking to this group of about 80 pastors, and I always throw out this junk question at the beginning.
I say, “Do any of you pastors have more active men than women in your church?” And nobody ever raises their hands. Well, this one particular time, this one teeny little hand rose up in the back and this particular hand had nail polish on it. And so I kind of looked and it’s this petite woman, five foot two, she’s a female pastor in a Methodist church in the middle of a cornfield in a little town in Illinois. And I said, “Perhaps you didn’t hear my question right. I asked if you have more active men than women in your church.” She goes, “Oh yes, I do.” I said, “Well, how on earth is that possible?” I said, “What’s your name?” She goes, “Oh, my name is Reverend Jennifer Wilson. I’m the pastor of Grace United Methodist Church.” I said, “How is this possible? How do you have more men than women?” She goes, “Well, I read your book and I did everything you said.” So I later interviewed her, actually did a documentary about her, a 13-minute documentary called Amazing Grace: A Church for Men.
You can see it on YouTube or you can see it on my website. But what she did is she just began to make very man-friendly changes to her church. She repainted, she redecorated, she got the guys together on a regular basis. She designated a very strong guy as the men’s ministry leader, started leading more dangerous missions into the urban areas around Chicago and Illinois, bigger vision type things, put TVs up in the sanctuary just for projecting images, always plays videos off YouTube on Sunday, kept her sermons short. I mean, she basically created a more man-friendly environment. And in three years, her church doubled in size. She saw a huge growth among the young men. So just these little cultural changes reaped huge benefits, even with a woman in the pulpit. So I would say that any church out there, no matter what your size, no matter what your polity, no matter what you preach, you have a very strong avenue for growth if you’ll simply create an environment where men will sit and stay long enough to hear the gospel and have their lives transformed.
And that’s what churches around the country and around the world are doing by focusing more on their men and boys.
Brett McKay:
Fantastic. Well, David Murrow, thank you so much for your time. It’s been a pleasure.
David Murrow:
Thank you for having me on the show.
Brett McKay:
My guest today was David Murrow. He’s the author of the book, Why Men Hate Going to Church. It’s available on amazon.com. You can also find more information about David’s work at churchformen.com. Also check out the show notes at aom.is/murrow, where you can find links to resources where you can delve deeper into this topic.