Lessons in Manliness from Andrew Jackson

by Brett & Kate McKay on November 18, 2013 · 29 comments

in A Man's Life, Lessons In Manliness


“I was born for a storm and a calm does not suit me.”

While his countenance graces our $20 bill, many Americans do not know much about the life of Andrew Jackson. He is often remembered as the hero of the Battle of New Orleans or condemned as the man responsible for the Trail of Tears. He was in truth a man of many contradictions: impetuous and reckless frontiersman and charming gentleman; signer of the Indian Removal Act and devoted father of an adopted Indian orphan; champion of freedom and the preservation of the Union and unrepentant slave holder. He was described as both a quintessential man’s man, “fond of well-cut clothes, racehorses, dueling, newspapers, gambling, whiskey, coffee, a pipe, pretty women, children, and good company,” and a gentleman with a soft side: “there was more of the woman in his nature than in that of any man I ever knew — more of a woman’s tenderness toward children, and sympathy with them.”

He was the first president to come from the common people and break the Virginia aristocracy’s hold on that office. After his inauguration, he threw open the doors of the White House for a public reception; the crowd of drunken well-wishers who attended grew so huge and unruly they had to be lured back out with large tubs of spiked punch placed on the front lawn. He was the first president to see himself as the direct representative of the people and thus to believe that his office should have great power and authority in shaping national affairs.

There is much to find repugnant in Andrew Jackson’s life and career as it pertains to slavery and Native Americans. But that a man is flawed in some ways does not mean he cannot be inspiring in others, and it would be a shame not to learn from the high points of the life of “The Old Lion”:

Don’t Let Your Circumstances Determine Your Fate


Andrew Jackson’s life story could have been torn straight from a Horatio Alger novel. Jackson’s father died just 2 months before he was born. His mother could not keep the family farm going herself and moved in with her sister. So began a life of dependency for young Andrew. His aunt put his mother to work like a housekeeper, and the boy was always keenly aware of his inferior place in the household. Growing up without a father, he developed a propensity towards anger, recklessness, and defensiveness.

Yet Jackson’s troubles had just begun. The Revolutionary War would grant the country independence, but exact a heavy price on this future president. Hugh, his 16-year-old brother who had gone off to fight, became the first casualty, dying of heat exhaustion at the Battle of Stono Ferry. Andrew, who at age 13 had joined a local militia to serve as a courier, was then captured by British soldiers and imprisoned along with his other brother, Robert. Jackson’s mother successfully pled for the boys to be released, but Robert, who had contracted smallpox while in jail, died two days later. Andrew was also sick, but his mother, assured he was doing well, decided to travel to Charleston to tend to prisoners of war who had become stricken with cholera. Jackson would never see her again; she soon fell ill and passed away. Andrew Jackson, only 14 years old, was now an orphan.

Jackson now had no immediate family and only a few years of education. He lived with a series of relatives, chafed at feeling like an inferior houseguest, squandered an inheritance from his grandfather, and sowed his wild oats. His relatives feared he would become a great embarrassment to his family. He described his situation during this time as “homeless and friendless.”

Jackson felt deeply adrift, but his mother’s last advice to him before she departed for Charleston kept returning to his mind, urging him to turn things around and live a proper and successful life:

“Andrew, if I should not see you again, I wish you to remember and treasure up some things I have already said to you: in this world you will have to make your own way. To do that you must have friends. You can make friends by being honest, and you can keep them by being steadfast. You must keep in mind that friends worth having will in the long run expect as much from you as they give to you. To forget an obligation or be ungrateful for a kindness is a base crime — not merely a fault or a sin, but an actual crime. Men guilty of it sooner or later must suffer the penalty. In personal conduct be always polite but never obsequious. None will respect you more than you respect yourself. Avoid quarrels as long as you can without yielding to imposition. But sustain your manhood always. Never bring a suit in law for assault and battery or for defamation. The law affords no remedy for such outrages that can satisfy the feelings of a true man. Never wound the feelings of others. Never brook wanton outrage upon your own feelings. If you ever have to vindicate your feelings or defend your honor, do it calmly. If angry at first, wait until your wrath cools before you proceed.”

Desiring to honor the memory of his mother, Jackson tried to get back on track and decided to study and apprentice to become a lawyer. He was still living a rowdy life at that point –“I was a raw lad then, but I did my best,” Jackson would later recall — but he began to mark out a path for himself.

He was able to gain admittance to the bar but could not find any clients to represent; he had no clout or experience. So he leveraged the one quality that would help carry him all the way to the White House: his magnetic bearing and charisma. It was a time where connection to great and prosperous families was essential to success, and Jackson used his charm to insinuate himself into these families’ good graces. He was never considered attractive, but his gentlemanly manners, steely, attentive blue eyes, and ability to converse with and warmly engage with people from all walks of life drew others to him. While his rowdy reputation would often precede him, Jackson would instantly disarm those he met and absolutely confound their expectations.

Jackson made the right connections, worked hard, and moved up in the world. With vast stores of personal strength, self-confidence, and perseverance as his only resources, he set out to make a name for himself. His biographer, Jon Meacham, details his astonishing and unexpected rise: “An uneducated boy from the Carolina backwoods, the son of Scots-Irish immigrants…became a practicing lawyer, a public prosecutor, a US attorney, a delegate to the founding Tennessee Constitutional Convention, a US Congressman, a US Senator, a judge of the state Superior Court, and a major general, first of the state militia and then of the US Army.” And then, of course, he would reach the very top of the ladder – attaining the highest office in the land.

Instead of letting adversity break him, Andrew Jackson gathered a gritty strength from his experiences that would enable him to make it through all the tests and trials of his life.

Cultivate Your Leadership


Before he became a politician, Jackson was a great and storied war hero. He was the kind of leader that men would gladly follow to the ends of the earth. Having grown up without a father, Jackson sought to be a father to the men under his command. He treated his men as sons, and in so doing, won their undying loyalty.

When the war with Britain began in the winter of 1812-13, Major General Jackson gathered together 2,000 volunteers and marched them from Tennessee towards New Orleans in anticipation of action. The men had picked up and left behind their professions and families — their entire lives, really — in hopes of being of service to the country. But after journeying for 500 cold miles and reaching Mississippi, the Secretary of War ordered them to disband and return. Jackson refused to leave his volunteers adrift and force the men to find their own way back home. He promised to keep them together, and even use his own money to furnish the supplies necessary for the return trip.

Many of the men had by then fallen ill and could not make the long journey unaided. Yet there were only 11 wagons for the 150 sick men. The regiment’s doctor, Samuel Hogg, asked Jackson what he should do with the sick. “To do sir? You are not to leave a man on the ground.” “But the wagons are full and they will convey not more than half,” Hogg countered. “Then let some of the troops dismount, and the officers must give up their horses to the sick. Not a man, sir, must be left behind,” Jackson declared. The general set the example by immediately turning over his own horses. He walked alongside his men all the way back to Tennessee. By the time the weary troops arrived in Nashville, the men had taken to calling their tender but tough leader “Old Hickory,” a tree whose wood is described thusly: “Very hard, stiff, dense, and shock resistant. There are woods that are stronger than hickory and woods that are harder, but the combination of strength, toughness, hardness, and stiffness found in hickory wood is not found in any other.”

Prize Your Honor and the Honor of Your Loved Ones


One’s honor was a central occupation of all men during this period, but starting from a young age, Andrew Jackson took it even more seriously than most. During the Revolutionary War, when he and his brother were captured by the red coats, a British officer ordered Jackson to polish his boots. The nervy boy refused, declaring, “Sir, I am a prisoner of war and claim to be treated as such.” Enraged, the officer swung his sword at Jackson. Though he tried to block the blow, it left a scar on his hand and a dent in his head.

Jackson was also ferocious in his desire to protect the honor and well-being of his loved ones. The orphan drew his extended family to him and greatly valued their loyalty. Above all, he valued the bond and honor of his wife of 40 years, Rachel. Because their marriage began under a cloud of controversy (Rachel was not yet divorced when their relationship began), she was subject to attack from Jackson’s political opponents. To Jackson, the slanderer was “worse than a murderer. The murderer only takes the life of the parent and leaves his character as a goodly heritage to his children, whilst the slanderer takes away his good reputation and leaves him a living monument to his children’s disgrace.” Defaming his wife was, as a contemporary recalled, “like sinning against the Holy Ghost: unpardonable.” Biographer James Parton claimed that Jackson “kept pistols in perfect condition for thirty-seven years” to use whenever someone “dared breathe her name except in honor.”

They were dueling pistols. For a southern gentleman of this time, dueling was the honorable way to resolve quarrels and insults. Jackson took his mother’s maxim “that the law affords no remedy for such outrages that can satisfy the feelings of a true man” to heart, and involved himself in more than 13 “affairs of honor.” These showdowns left his body so filled with lead that people said he “rattled like a bag of marbles.”

Practice Stoic Self-Discipline


Jackson’s anger, born from his troubled youth, constantly threatened his ability to reach his goals. He knew he had to get it under control if he wished to find success. He was never able to entirely subdue his temper, but he was largely able to transform himself from reckless hothead to cool and calculating leader.

During his presidential campaigns, his opponents were constantly trying to provoke Jackson, goading him to lose control and reveal himself as exactly what some voters feared him to be: a knuckle-dragging, unhinged frontiersmen, unfit for the highest office in the land. Though they besmirched the character of his wife, Jackson’s great Achilles’ heel, he would not give them the satisfaction of an embarrassing outburst.

The election of 1824 was a particularly bitter contest. Jackson had won the popular vote, but without a majority from the electoral college, the decision was thrown to the House, which chose John Quincy Adams to be the next president. On the night he lost the election, Jackson attended a party at the White House where he came face-to-face with Adams. The moment was tense as the two men stared at one another. With his wife on his arm, it was Jackson who made the first move, extending his hand to the president-elect and cheerfully inquiring, “How do you do, Mr. Adams? I give you my left hand, for the right, as you see, is devoted to the fair. I hope you are very well, sir.” Answering with what an eyewitness recalled as “chilling coldness” Adams responded: “Very well, sir; I hope General Jackson is well.” A party guest was struck by the irony of the exchange: “It was curious to see the western planter, the Indian fighter, the stern soldier, who had written his country’s glory in the blood of the enemy at New Orleans, genial and gracious in the midst of a court, while the old courtier and diplomat was stiff, rigid, cold as a statue!”

Be a Badass


Andrew Jackson was the first president on which an assassination attempt was made. And he is the only one who gave his would-be assassin a thorough thumping.

In 1835, Jackson was leaving a funeral when a deranged man, Richard Lawrence, approached the president wielding two pistols. Lawrence leveled one of his guns and pulled the trigger. It failed to fire. He pointed at Jackson with the other pistol, but it misfired as well. Without blinking, the 68-year-old president went after Lawrence with his cane, striking him several times before others in the crowd subdued the would-be assassin.

But Jackson’s greatest claim to badass status actually came years earlier. In 1806, in a dispute over a horse race and an insult made about his wife, Charles Dickinson challenged Jackson to a duel. Dickinson was a well-known sharpshooter and Jackson felt his only chance to kill him would be to allow himself enough time to take an accurate shot. So as the two faced off along the banks of the Red River in Kentucky, Jackson purposely allowed Dickinson to shoot him first. He hardly quivered as the bullet lodged in his ribs. Jackson then calmly leveled his pistol, took aim, and knocked Dickinson off. It was only then that he took heed of the fact that blood was dripping into his boot. Dickinson’s musket ball was too close to his heart to be removed and forever remained lodged in Jackson’s chest. The wound would lend him a perpetual hacking cough, cause him persistent pain, and compound the many health problems that would beleaguer him throughout life.

Yet Jackson never regretted the decision, saying, “If he had shot me through the brain, sir, I should still have killed him.”



American Lion by Jon Meacham

Andrew Jackson by James Curtis


{ 29 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Isaac Dillman November 18, 2013 at 6:16 pm

Great and terrible, all at the same time. I was waiting for the story of the Benton Brothers and their brawl with Jackson in Nashville.

2 Andrew November 18, 2013 at 6:43 pm

Despite some of the above mentioned flaws, Jackson has always remained one of my favorite Presidents. Great article, Brett and Kate!

3 Deeter November 18, 2013 at 8:37 pm

Jackson has an incredible legacy and is an archetypal ‘hero of the people’.

One thing I wonder is what the limits to the defence of honour are. Brett, is there a time or way that a man can value honour too highly?

4 Sahaj November 18, 2013 at 8:39 pm

Andrew Jackson quote: “I have only two regrets: I didn’t shoot Henry Clay and I didn’t hang John C. Calhoun.” It should be noted that Calhoun was Jackson’s vice president.

5 Staph A November 18, 2013 at 8:59 pm

I only ever read about Jackson in regards to his role in almost wiping out the Cherokee Indians for a history of genocide class so I’m glad you guys brought it up before getting into how awesomely manly he also was. He’s definitely a complex and fascinating character. Great article!

6 Tom November 18, 2013 at 10:09 pm

It is a major pity that you did not mention Jackson and the Bank War.


7 Nick November 18, 2013 at 10:47 pm

He certainly was a remarkable character and a manly gentleman.

But… I find it hard to admire or respect someone that was so involved in genocide.
He’s still my least favorite president by far.

But, I learned something. It was a good article at least.

8 Jeremy November 18, 2013 at 11:29 pm

Jackson was a complicated man. I have both defended him and listed his “wrongs”, sometime in the same discussion. I am a historian and historical re-enactor, with my primary focus being the Creek and Seminole peoples. I do find some of his actions impressive, but I don’t think I would have chosen him as an example of manliness. He has done too many things that were bad examples. I am not just referring to the Indian Removal Act, which was not solely his fault – the Congress of the time had to approve it first, after all, but his obsessive hatred of the British, his tendency to only obey orders as he saw them (invading Spanish Florida against orders and killing two British traders), his poor treatment of the Creek and Cherokee, his disregard of the Supreme Court of the time (they ruled the Removal Act unconstitutional and upheld the Cherokee’s case against the government), and the above mentioned dueling, all are reasons not to praise him. Also, I have seen in my reading that his adoption of a Creek boy has been questioned. I do feel however, that he was a success as a U.S. President – he did pretty well fulfill all of his goals as Commander-in-Chief, which is something many presidents before and after have failed at. Perhaps another PotUS may have been a better example of manliness than Jackson. Washington, perhaps. I know you have written about Teddy Roosevelt, who I think is a fine example of manliness. But I think Jackson is just too controversial/complicated to be a good example.

9 Steve November 19, 2013 at 5:10 am

Great Article on a hero of manliness !

10 Adrian November 19, 2013 at 7:12 am

Certainly all men are flawed, but learning lessons from as flawed as this seems like a bad plan. Young men who are reading this blog may take the wrong lesson from this.

There are no shortage of admirable and less flawed men. Do profiles on them instead.

11 Emmanuel M'M November 19, 2013 at 7:19 am

Inspiring. Not painted with a rose-tinted brush.

Shows us a man with weakness who mastered his passions

12 Westicles November 19, 2013 at 7:29 am

Great post!

13 Richard November 19, 2013 at 7:47 am

With regards to the assassination attempt, an inspection of the two guns afterwards could not find a single reason why they would have not fired.

It’s been suggested that the bullets were too afraid of what Jackson might have done to them…

14 Doug November 19, 2013 at 8:52 am

I agree with Tom. That was a huge part of his presidency. Jackson’s dying words were, “I killed the Bank.” Other than that, a fantastic article, one that wasn’t afraid to highlight the good as well as the bad.

15 Marcus November 19, 2013 at 9:58 am

This is a great article! However, some of the facts are wrong. I’ll only point of the most obvious one saying that “[Jackson] was the first president to come from the common people and break the Virginia aristocracy’s hold on that office.” John Adams, a Boston lawyer, was actually the first POTUS to break the line of “Virginia aristocracy’s hold on that office.”

16 Eric Davis November 19, 2013 at 9:59 am
17 Claude November 19, 2013 at 12:09 pm

I’ve only known the bad things until now. Very interesting. Thanks.

18 Jon E November 19, 2013 at 12:12 pm

Honor is badass.

19 Nathan E. November 19, 2013 at 7:27 pm

Good article, I’m with Tom at being disappointed that you failed to mention his opposition to the banks and what his last words were.
Good read though.

20 Rufus November 19, 2013 at 8:13 pm

Don’t apologize Brett. The truth is many policies today have affected more people than the “trail of tears” such as the liberal abortion agenda which targets African Americans, and has come to be referred to as black genocide. But you see no one going around regretting Obama’s fault for defending planned parenthood. The truth is while people are debating the ethics of historical figures in order to make their own selves feel better (pointing out the faults of Jackson or Jefferson), they ignore the true characters of men like Jackson and Jefferson, which are far superior to 99 percent of men today.

21 Luke Phillips November 20, 2013 at 9:02 am

Excellent article!!! I always like your brief biographies and meditations on great men. I think it would be wonderful if you did something similar to this about Alexander Hamilton; Ron Chernow’s biography is excellent source material.

22 Philip Quim November 20, 2013 at 1:40 pm

If he were an Indian Chief, and did to the white settlers what he did to the Indians, would you still consider him an example of manliness?

23 DaleK November 20, 2013 at 2:46 pm

Great article and very insightful.
Some of the critics may be correct; as Andrew Jackson had his detractors.

What I have learned over time however is to be open-minded long enough to see what I can learn from articles before I start finding fault with them.

That said, I found two points that really rung true to me.

One – there is nothing wrong with being a complex, confusing individual; tailoring our outward demeanor to fit the circumstances.

Two – Having a generally abrasive, decisive and forward personality – while reserving a tender, sympathetic side to children is NOT weird. I have known some great men who did this.

It is our modern, popular culture that demands men should be of one personality for all things. And that culture can go to thunder.

24 Chickasha Hoolba November 20, 2013 at 3:57 pm

As a Chickasaw I believe, with tongue in cheek, that Jackson was the Antichrist (or maybe at least one of the four horsemen) but this article was a fascinating look into a highly colorful and controversial figure; a reminder that one must have respect for one’s enemies. I salute Crockett for standing up to him in Congress at the cost of his own political career.

25 Brian November 20, 2013 at 4:21 pm

I just had to comment saying what a suave badass he was.

26 Brett McKay November 21, 2013 at 1:22 am

His opposition to the bank was a political stance rather than a character trait, which is the focus of Lessons in Manliness.

Most definitely.

27 Dave November 22, 2013 at 9:42 pm

Fantastic article. Keep up the good work.


28 Jim January 11, 2014 at 3:20 pm

Andrew Jackson, definitely a controversial figure, perhaps the most unashamedly human of all our presidents, revealing the real man and not a carefully crafted idol. Refreshing, really. Would that there were someone on the political landscape now who was not the product of endless spin-doctoring.

The greatest legacy of Jackson, is a lesson in history that our leaders of the last century and this have apparently failed to learn, to our eternal detriment, that is, Jackson’s single minded efforts to keep Europe’s Central Bankers from establishing a foothold in this country. (ie, the Bank War), and ultimately ruling in place of elected officials, against the common good.

29 Jim S January 12, 2014 at 9:30 pm

I am 50 and the older I become, the more I realize that even the greatest among us have terrible faults. None are perfect so I believe having AJ as an example of manliness is fitting because he has many character traits that the would make up the perfect man. If you would have known him as a friend you would have been fortunate. Teddy is still the best PREZ who ever drew a breath. Where are the TR,s?

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

Site Meter