The Art of Winemaking: Part I

by A Manly Guest Contributor on April 13, 2011 · 22 comments

in Blog

Editor’s Note: This is a guest post from Matthew Nagy. Matthew has worked as a vintage winemaker in California, New York, and New Zealand.

Let’s face it. Wine rarely conjures up the same aura of manliness that a good scotch or a great stout does. But many of the eminent men of history have enjoyed and delighted in a nice glass of red or white. From Caesar and Louis XIV to Jefferson and Franklin, men have been enjoying wine for thousands of years.

In this first segment of a two part series, we will be discussing the basics of production for both the professional and the amateur. In part two, we will turn our attention to the basics of wine knowledge–the key regions, history, and styles that will enable one to speak intelligently on the topic and make confident purchasing and tasting decisions.

It Begins with the Earth

Like all things that originate in nature, the earth where the grape is grown is the single most important aspect in our craft. The French refer to it as terrior, that little bit of je ne sais quoi that turns a good wine into a great wine. It’s true that science can offer no tangible explanation for why wine from one location can and will taste better than wine that comes from grapes grown 100 yards away, but the human taste buds do not lie and appreciable differences can often be found. Apart from soil, the three other major components that make the most difference to great wine are temperature, rainfall, and humidity. Working in New York is completely different than working in California, and the same seed of Merlot planted in both locations can yield drastically different results.

In early winter, the process starts. All of the shoots that bore last year’s fruit are cut back to the rootstock so that new vines will grow once again come springtime.  We prune so that we can control the amount of growth of each vine from the very beginning, helping to maintain the quality of the fruit that we will produce.

After lying dormant in the cold of winter, spring is possibly the most crucial time for the plant. Springtime is when the vines flower into what will eventually become the clusters of grapes that will produce the wine. We call this the fruit set, and this is where rainfall and temperature can wreak havoc on the year’s crop from its very onset. Excessive spring rain can lead to latent mildew spores that will lie dormant until fall, when they can multiply in a late heat or rain and have a damaging effect on the quality and flavor of the fruit that comes into the winery. A hard frost that hits the East Coast during the fruit set could halt the growth of over half of the grapes-to-be and ruin a vintage by May.  One of the reasons that California and the West Coast in general have taken hold of the American wine market is the moderate springs that generally bring fewer frosts and less rain than we see on the eastern seaboard.  Another benefit that California has is that summers are free of humidity (a cause of mildew and mold) and rainfall (too much rain causes the grapes to saturate with water and lose their flavor concentration).  Freedom from these variables makes the summer a relatively stress-free time in the vineyards, where only management of the canopy is really needed until harvest.

The Harvest

Harvest is the single most critical and stressful time for any winery or winemaker during the calendar year. Hours become longer and days off become non-existent for months at a time as the fruit begins to come in and the delicate process of fermentation starts in earnest. Nearly all wineries follow the same basic picking order for their production: sparkling wine first, then whites, and then reds. Because sparkling wines are fermented twice, they are picked with slightly higher acid levels than other white wines, so that they will stand up better to the added sugar of the second fermentation and still taste crisp and not too sweet in its final form. White wine grapes generally reach full ripeness faster than red wine grapes, and thus the end result is somewhat lower in alcohol than most of the reds that are made today. The longer grapes sit on the vine maturing, the more sugar is found in each individual berry. For the purposes of fermentation, Sugar=Alcohol.

Without getting too deep into the scientific details, fermentation for the winemaking process is where yeast, either introduced to the juice or wild, converts the sugar from the grape juice into ethanol and carbon dioxide gas.  The ripeness of the grape directly correlates to the amount of sugar that can be converted in this process, and that is one of the main determining factors in choosing when to harvest.

Matthew empties a red tank after fermentation.

One of the biggest challenges of harvest is managing the intake of fruit into the winery. Too much fruit all at once and you will run out of vessels to store it in, but move too slowly and the grapes that are left on the vine can become susceptible to rot and over-ripening–essentially turning into raisins. So that means our job during harvest is to get the fruit in as quickly as possible while still maintaining the highest levels of quality. Days lasting longer than 15 hours per shift, or even 24 hour rotations at the bigger wineries are commonplace.  Let’s take a look at the harvest timeline for whites and reds:

  • First the fruit is brought in, sorted to weed out the bad grapes, leaves, and vineyard waste.
  • The second step with white wine is to press all of the juice out of the clusters of grapes. In making white wine, you want to minimize the amount of contact the juice has with the skins, seeds, and stems of the grape. That is the source of tannin, which can leave white wine with harsh and bitter notes when it is turned into wine.  In contrast, you want those tannins in red wines, so instead of pressing the juice right away, the juice is moved into a tank with all of the skins, seeds, and stems included to macerate together and extract tannins.
  • The third step with white wine is to allow the juice to settle at a cold temperature, letting final bits of dirt or other impurities settle to the bottom of a tank. Then the juice is taken into a second tank with a pump. The sediment again settles to the bottom, and the juice is pumped out until the sediment is reached and the juice no longer runs clear. This clean juice is then ready for fermentation. We call this “racking” the wine. Because the red wine has been soaking in its skins and seeds, this step is skipped.
  • Now both red and white juices are ready for their respective fermentations. Some wineries will choose to inoculate the juice with cultured yeast to ensure a stable fermentation, while others will choose to let the indigenous yeast that is present in the winery and vineyard do the work for them. It is totally at the winemaker’s discretion on which way to go, and depending on the style of wine they are making, they will choose accordingly. Fermentations can last for up to a month or longer, in both red and white wine.
  • After fermentation is complete, white wines are again “racked” off of the sediment created during fermentation, leaving clean wine ready to be aged. Red wine will be drained clean out of their tanks, and the remaining trapped juice, seeds, stems, and everything else (the must) will be pressed and separated into wine later used for blending.

That is the basic harvest process, and after its completion, it is off to the barrel room for the wines to be aged, and for the winemaker and their staff to get some much needed rest. This whole process can take as little as two stress-filled months, or last around four or five.

Patience Is a Virtue

Matthew monitors the fermentation of white wine in barrel during the harvest.

After everyone has rested up and taken a holiday, the process of barrel aging begins. Many white wines will skip this step, like Sauvignon Blanc and lighter styled Chardonnays; instead, these wines will sit in a stainless steel tank until it is time for them to be blended and bottled. But, for some whites, and almost every red, the next step is to be aged in French, American, or Hungarian oak barrels for around 6 to 18 months–longer in rare cases. Introducing the new wine to oak will soften the tannins that were present in the skins and impart the flavor of the barrels themselves into the wine.

Barrel selection is a careful process, with many factors considered, such as the cooperage, the country of origin, and whether or not the barrel is considered “new.” Indeed, the most important element in barrel selection is old versus “new.” For the purposes of the winemaker, a new barrel is one that has been used once prior, or brand new from the cooperage. The old barrels are considered “neutral,” as they will not impart any wood flavors into the wine. The ratio of new and old barrels is a huge determining factor in the style of wine that is made.

Most of the work in the cellar during this time of the year is spent topping the barrels to ensure they are full, which prevents oxidation and ensures that the wine is properly sulfured. Sulfur gas or liquid is the main preservative used in wine, as it inhibits oxidization.  Attention this time of year will again be turned to the vineyard for pruning, fruit set, and canopy maintenance until it is time to blend and bottle.

The Fruits of Our Labor

Unlike fine scotches, which are almost exclusively single malt or even single barrel, the finest wines are usually a blend of the best fruit and vineyards that are available to each winery.  Almost no wine is made with 100% of a single type of grape, even if it says so on the label. Wine from every barrel or barrel type is sampled and tasted independently. After being given a grade, the best scores will be considered for the top flight blends and tasted and mixed again and again until everything is just right on the winemaker’s palate and nose.

A great palate and nose is akin to the golden goose for winemakers, and many reputations are made by the ability to blend masterfully and consistently. Smaller wineries will pay a small fortune to have a reputed winemaker consult for each vintage of wine they produce, sometimes paying him over six figures for just a few days work.

With blends done, the dirty and mundane work of filtering and bottling comes up later in the summertime. Often the bottling of a past vintage will overlap with the start of the current harvest and the winemaker’s year is complete.

I hope you enjoyed this primer on winemaking. In part two we will discuss the different styles, varietals, and regions in the wine world and give you an idea of how to start tasting and enjoying the fruits of our craft.

{ 22 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Chris Homan April 13, 2011 at 12:30 pm

I enjoy a glass or two of wine every so often. There’s a great winery here in Ohio, about 30 minutes from my house, that offers some wonderful wines that I frequently indulge in. I tend more toward sweet wines, but there are a few dry wines I like, too.

2 James April 13, 2011 at 12:52 pm

I enjoy some good wine. Beer brewing seems more approachable, but making wine seems like it would be fun as well.

3 Bryan Schatz April 13, 2011 at 1:32 pm

I’ve yet to develop much of a palate for wine, but I loved reading this article and appreciate the patience and craftsmanship involved in the process. Very cool.

4 ed April 13, 2011 at 1:45 pm


Winemaking is easier than it would seem. The local homebrew shop probably has a kit. The good thing about winemaking is you don’t have to cook anything. We usually brew beer out in the backyard to avoid cleanup and spousal complaints. Winemaking does take more time overall because of the need to rack and age.

5 Zach April 13, 2011 at 1:52 pm

Wine and wine making is plenty manly; It’s all about dirt really. I know “high wine culture” can be quite obnoxious, but I’d try to get more into your local wine scene or search for “wine library tv” by a guy named Gary Vaynerchuk.

6 Benjamin April 13, 2011 at 3:00 pm

A good Red is good with a good steak.
But in doesnt even compare with the manly feeling you get from drinking a good peaky scotch. Like drinking a mix of liquid leather, a campfire, and a Cinnamon vanilla covered oak.

7 Jason April 13, 2011 at 3:34 pm

I’ll stick to Miller Light.

8 Geno April 13, 2011 at 4:52 pm

This was certainly informative; thank you for writing the article. I’m still working on developing a sense of taste in wine myself, but this certainly clarified some of the mysteries of wine for me.

9 Kyle April 13, 2011 at 6:11 pm

Taste buds may not lie, but brains sure do. And those always have to contend competing influences such your wallet and wine reputations/reviews.

entering the world of wine can be bewildering; don’t let anyone tell you what is or isn’t good. Keep track of your own tastes and you’ll find the right ones for you.

10 Ben April 13, 2011 at 6:44 pm

I’ve got a lot of respect for vintners, the people who grow the grapes. Their work is back breaking. While there are automated planters and harvesters, on many vineyards, particularly smaller ones, at least the harvesting is done by hand.

@james @ed agreed! You’re best bet is to get a kit. That’s a good way to get started since all the equipment you need, ingredients, instructions, etc. are usually all included.

11 Hudzo April 13, 2011 at 7:54 pm

I’ve been a home winemaker for several years now. The equipment is fairly simple and you can get started for under $100. If you live near a vineyard, sometimes they’ll sell you grapes, or even give it you you if you go help with their harvest. I’ve turned out some pretty good stuff and some pretty awful stuff; it’s all about learning from your mistakes and keeping good notes. You can make wine from pretty much anything: grapes, peaches, berries… the best wine I’ve ever produced was from dandelions.

12 Dan April 13, 2011 at 9:50 pm

Wow, it’s like AoM reads my mind. I recently moved into a place with like a 12′x20′ grapes trellis that produced many grapes last summer. Hoping to use them for something other than food for the local raccoons.

13 CSEAUX April 13, 2011 at 11:53 pm

I have been making my own wine now for the past three years. It is very simple to do and
the only part I find a little tedious is the cleaning of the equipment and even then after a few tries and procedures it has become quite simple. Yes, the quote unquote wine enthusiast can be a little doubtful in the taste and texture of homemade wines but what they don’t appreciate is the patience, time, and care it takes to make your own wine.

14 TC April 14, 2011 at 6:21 am

Sheer pedantry, I know, but it’s “terroir”, not “terrior”.

If you’re in the UK, it seems to be impossible to see the word “terroir” and not get a mental image of Oz Clarke :)

15 Jordan W April 14, 2011 at 8:59 am

I began my wine journey about 5 years ago and now it’s a huge part of my life. Here’s how I suggest people start learning about wine:

-Taste a bunch of different wines and keep a journal. Think about what you’re smelling and tasting and try to relate it to something you know (cherry cough syrup, bubble gum, cotton candy, skittles, leather, butter, whatever). Don’t worry too much about “wine words”.
-If you find a varietal or region that you like, explore it. I spent a lot of time geeking out on Malbec, Cote du Rhone GSM blends, Petit Verdot, Australian Shiraz, Spanish Crianza, etc.
-Have some fun and check out Gary at or
-Attend as many tastings as you can.
-Drink lots of wine! Did I emphasize that enough? I don’t really care too much about the stuff in the thick wine encyclopedias out there… just taste lots of wine!
-Find a ‘QPR’ (Quality to Price ratio) that works for you. Often wines at a certain price will bring a certain quality (Not always!). This has slowly crept up for me from ~$15 bottles to ~$19 to ~$25 as my wine tastes mature, but I still enjoy many of the less expensive wines.

Hope this helps someone.

16 Carter April 14, 2011 at 12:44 pm

Wine country, now that would be a good trip to take the wife on.

17 JR Seaman April 14, 2011 at 3:17 pm

Wine is amazing. The more you learn the more you respect it and want it. It is a hard art that I hope to make a reality one day. If you want to get into it (do what the others have said.) Watch wine library tv or the daily grape, read a good book (window on the world of wine), and watch a good movie like bottle shock.

18 Mitch April 14, 2011 at 9:20 pm

I feel the need to point out that most “scotches” (whiskies) are not single malt. In fact, about 90% of all spirit distilled in Scotland is intended for blends rather than malts.

I know this article is about wine rather than whisky but I hate to see misinformation about whisky, which is one of my great passions in life.

19 Soappeddler April 15, 2011 at 8:47 am

I find that brewing beer and making meed are more satisfying for me. That’s probably because I enjoy drinking beer and mead more than wine. Beer is more of an adventure to make, but is ready for drinking sooner than wine is.

Making mead is very similar to making wine with the exception that you are using honey instead of grapes.

20 Danko April 16, 2011 at 3:21 pm

“Let’s face it. Wine rarely conjures up the same aura of manliness that a good scotch or a great stout does.”

- Absolutely disagree. This might be true in USA, but in rest of the world, real men drink wine, make wine and are considered on higher level than hard liquor. Wine is toughest, most difficult to make and there is nothing easy about it.
I am a beer person myself, but have made wine with my own hands in my father’s vineyard and whine cellar.

21 DR April 18, 2011 at 8:37 pm

I’ll always hold admiration for the creators of liquor. It involves such patience and so much else, but the final product is incredibly rewarding (for the most part)!

Also, as much as I love wine, enjoying a scotch after a long day is always better.

22 Chris April 28, 2011 at 3:47 am

Excellent article.
You’d be surprised at where wine can be made! In places like Idaho– which is actually like Spain, and in Canada, which is colder than you’d think wine grapes would be able to deal with. So I’d check out the local area for ‘wine country’! :)

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

Site Meter