Why Being “Indie” is a Bunch of Bunk

by Brett & Kate McKay on August 10, 2008 · 102 comments

in A Man's Life

The term “indie” has a somewhat amorphous meaning. Once applied strictly to underground music and films that were not made or financed by large corporations, the label can now be applied to a whole culture. Still, it’s hard to pin down exactly what it means. So I turn to that great and reliable resource, Wikipedia:

“The most general definition of the word is to be independent from the mainstream. The word has become most often associated with a subculture defined by its associated music, fashion, behavior and beliefs. Indie culture is a lifestyle which follows social trends that are considered to consciously deviate from the mainstream. One common belief within indie culture is anti-conformity.”

Many, including the entry of Wikipedia from which I gleaned that quote, have pointed out the irony that the indie culture, while seeking to be unique and independent, has developed a somewhat uniform and readily identifiable aesthetic. Indie connoisseurs wish to be different but are surrounded by a cadre of people who dress the same, watch the same movies, listen to the same “underground” music, and spew the same arguments denouncing the banal bourgeoisie.

But such a point is overdone and easy. I’d like to explore another reason that being indie is a bunch of bunk.

The indie identity is based on the idea of being independent from the mainstream. To this end, indie people buy clothes, CD’s, furniture, books, food, and concert and movie tickets that are not popular with the masses. Instead of going to Chili’s, they frequent their local Thai restaurant; instead of going to Wal-Mart, they go to Whole Foods; instead of picking up the new Coldplay CD, they buy an album from Blood Red Shoes; instead of shopping at the Gap, they buy from American Apparel; instead of buying a Dell they buy an Apple (sure they’re a big corporation, but they’re so cool). But what is the common denominator in all of those things? Spending money. Consumption. Indie people express their independence from the mainstream by doing the single most mainstream thing possible: basing their identity on what they consume.

A decade ago it was cool to wear clothing with a company’s logo splashed all over it. Nike and Gap labels were proudly displayed as badges of honor. These days such clothing is considered laughable; now shoppers want clothes that look unique or vintage (although frequently that “vintage” tee costs $40). But the underlying motivation remains the same; people are still expressing themselves by the clothes they buy. It doesn’t matter that instead of buying things from big corporations you buy free trade coffee, organic apples, and handmade Guatemalan rugs, you’re still basing your personal identity on your identity as a consumer. You are driven by the desire to consume something first before it is consumed by the masses. It’s the new millennium’s take on “keeping up with the Jonses.” And it’s just as conformist as it was in the 50′s.

Of course there is nothing wrong with liking certain kinds of music or clothing; it is entirely possible for a man to be interested in, and consume, all the aforementioned indie products, and yet not base his identity on them. But all too often such consumption is used to buy a persona, instead of actually putting in the work to it takes to attain an authentic one. Such accouterments instantly bestow some hipster cred but do nothing to transform the inner man. A man’s identity literally becomes a coat that can be put on or taken off, and there’s nothing cool about that.

Free yourself from being defined by what you buy or do not buy. Define yourself by the things you cannot purchase: values, ethics, and what you actually do. Let your actions speak louder than your ironic message tee. Want to be truly independent from mainstream society?

-Use your free time to serve people, not numb you mind with entertainment.

-Be virtuous

-Be courteous

-Stop “finding yourself” and embrace commitment and responsibility

-Don’t wear outdoorsy apparel, go camping

-Don’t spend big bucks to look like you shop at a thrift store, actually shop at one

-Don’t be ironic and sarcastic, be sincerely passionate

-Don’t just buy clothes and cell phones that support a charity, become charitable

-Don’t just buy a political bumper sticker, get involved in politics

-Stop being a boy and man up

Image by Suburban Cowboy

{ 102 comments… read them below or add one }

101 Caw Caw April 29, 2010 at 8:39 pm

@ Caw
No, the crows are calling my name!

102 Brenton June 23, 2010 at 11:50 am

Wow, this article sure has generated quite a bit of controversy. I clicked on the link to it because as soon as I read the title I knew the comments would be interesting and heated. I certainly wasn’t dissapointed ;)

I’d like to say I agree with the generalized (oops, that’s a bad word around these parts) tone of the commentary so far; that being that while the article made a very valid point, it used the ‘indie’ culture as a poor scapegoat illustration. I would consider myself ‘indie’ only as far as not letting myself be influenced by popular culture and commercialism and trying to find real meaning in my life. To be perfectly honest, in my personal experience, maybe 50% of the ‘indie’ people I know and socialize with fit this bill. Half of them are genuinely concerned with making their lives more meaningful and less controlled by society, and the other half are along for the ride, very much in the way the author describes it.

It is a pity that the author chose this stereotype as a medium for his frustration against buying an identity, but I totally agree with the point personally. If you base any part, absolutely any part of your self-identity or self-image on how others perceive you or how others perceive the products you subscribe to, you are quite the tool. Sincerely, if you need some kind of product to identify yourself with a group of people, especially one that’s designed for that very purpose, you’re a tool.

That being said, one thing I’ve learned from my ‘true indie’ friends is how to be accepting and think thoughtfully about other cultures and perspectives, and it’s done me some good. As a passionate musician, I’d say the 50/50 rule applies again to the ‘indie’ music I’ve heard; half of it is really good and satisfying, half of it is poorly thought-out junk.

Coda: If you’re going to use blatantly incorrect grammar or spelling in your posts, I’ll generally disregard your opinions straight-away. For real, think about what you write.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

Site Meter