The Decline of Male Space

by Brett on January 10, 2010 · 117 comments

in A Man's Life, On Manhood

Once upon a time, the world belonged to men.

Literally.

Because men had exclusive power in both private and public life, they controlled their surrounding environment and the way in which space was designed and decorated. Consequently, the world was once a very masculine place.

Thankfully, we’ve made progress in the area of gender equality and women have brought their influence to bear in both the home and the workplace. However, as with many other areas of modern life, the pendulum has swung from one extreme to the other; instead of creating a world that’s friendly to both male and female space, we’ve created one that benefits female space at the expense of male space.

What’s behind the decline in male space and the proliferation of female space? It’s actually a complex and interesting story that goes all the way back to 18th century. Below we’ll explore some of the factors that have contributed to the near eradication of male space in both public and private life.

Decline of Male Space in the Public Sphere

For most of humanity, the public sphere was solely a man’s domain. Up until as far as the 19th century, it wasn’t even appropriate for women to visit outside the home without a man accompanying her.

However, in the last 100 years, areas designated as male space have shrunk because of changes in attitudes towards gender and anti-discrimination laws.

In this section we discuss five public spaces that were once exclusively for men: the workplace, the bar, the barbershop, the gym, and the fraternal lodge/social club.

The workplace. Perhaps the largest male space in public life was the workplace. For many families in the West, the Industrial Revolution created a strict division of labor where men worked in a factory or office and women stayed home to take care of the children. If women did work, they largely did so in “female” industries like textile factories. As a result, the workplace was a predominately male space with rules and a culture that favored male sensibilities.

When women started to enter the workforce in greater numbers during the 1950s and 60s, many men saw it as an encroachment into their space and resorted to crude sexual harassment as a way to keep women “in their place.” Thanks to laws during the Civil Rights era and an increasing sensitivity and desire by businesses to create non-hostile workplaces, such harassment is seen for what it is and shunned by most males today.

The Bar. For centuries, a man could visit a bar and be in the exclusive presence of other men. Because drinking was seen as a corrupting influence on the “purity and innocence” of women, bars were completely off limits to ladies (exceptions were made for prostitutes, of course). Out of the presence of women and children, men could open up more and revel in their masculinity over a mug of cold ale. However, the bar as a men’s only hangout would quickly see its demise during the dry years of Prohibition.

By banning alcohol, Prohibition forced drinking underground. Speakeasy owners, desperate to make a buck, accepted all drinkers into their establishments, regardless of gender. Moreover, the economic and political empowerment women experienced during the 1920s and 30s made drinking by women more acceptable. By the time Prohibition was repealed, the female presence at the local watering hole had become a common appearance.

World War II only further eroded the male exclusivity of bars and pubs. As more women entered the workforce, it became acceptable to socialize with their male co-workers in taverns and lounges after work.

Today, there aren’t many bars around that cater only to men (gay bars being an obvious exception). Instead, bars have become a place where the sexes come together to mingle and look for a special someone (even if just for the night.)

Barbershops. Back in the 19th and early 20th centuries, barbershops were bastions of manliness, and one could be found on every corner. At the barbershop, a man could get a sharp haircut, enjoy a relaxing shave, and take part in some manly banter with his barber and the other customers. Unfortunately, several factors led to the decline of barbershops. Perhaps the biggest factor was the rise of the unisex salon. Places like “SuperCuts,” which were neither beauty salons nor barbershops, catered to both men and women. Many states’ licensing boards accelerated this trend by ceasing to issue barber licenses altogether in favor of offering a unisex “cosmetologist” license to all those seeking to enter the hair cutting profession.

Unlike the bar or workplace, the barbershop hasn’t been infiltrated by women; most ladies prefer the salon and wouldn’t dream of having Old George take the clippers to their head. Rather, barbershops have simply become harder to find. Even if you do find one, don’t be surprised if Old George has been replaced with Georgia.

Boxing Clubs and Gyms. Like bars, boxing clubs and gyms were once exclusively male-only haunts. In the time of women-free gyms, men could focus solely on building their bodies and not worry about impressing the ladies. They were dark, dingy places, that smelled of sweat and exhaustion. Free from the sound of Lady Gaga blasted over the speakers, the only noise was of grunts and the clanging of weights. However, in response to the women’s movement, many states and cities passed ordinances prohibiting male-only businesses and clubs. As a result, women advanced on gyms along with step classes and leotards.

Despite these anti-discrimination ordinances, many states have overlooked the proliferation of female-only gyms like Curves that have opened up across the country. Even when men bring lawsuits challenging these all-women establishments, they’re often dismissed. This unfortunate double standard has only aided in the decline of male space and the rise of female space.

Old school boxing clubs have also been in decline for several years. For many men growing up in the 1920s and 1930s, visiting the boxing gym as a boy was as normal as playing video games is for boys of today. The decline in the number of boxing gyms parallels the decline in the popularity of the sport itself. And some of the boxing clubs that are left  have understandably looked to stay afloat by offering “boxing cardio” classes that appeal to women. However, the popularity of mixed martial arts among young men may spur the creation of new male space in the form of MMA gyms. Few females  have found an interest in learning the ground and pound.

Fraternal Lodges and Social Clubs. Fraternal lodges and all male clubs and restaurants have a long and storied history in the United States and in other countries in the West. During the 19th and early 20th centuries, men flocked to fraternal lodges, like the Freemasons and the Odd Fellows, in order to take part in male fellowshipping. At one time in American history, 1 in 4 men belonged to a fraternal lodge of some sort. However, by 1950 membership began to decline as the demands of family life and work increased, leaving men little time for lodge life. Moreover, under pressure from women’s rights groups, some lodges allowed women to join their ranks. But for the most part fraternal lodges remain all-male. Their biggest problem is just recruiting new and younger members.

In addition to fraternal lodges, male only clubs and restaurants served as a place where a man could enjoy a nice rib-eye with their bros and get candid advice on their career and family life. But male-only clubs would start to feel the squeeze when the U.S. Supreme Court held in 1987 that states and cities may constitutionally ban sex discrimination by business-oriented private clubs. With this green light from the Court, many states and cities started cracking down on male-only clubs and restaurants. New York City was especially vigorous in prosecuting male-only clubs. Perhaps the most famous instance of a once male-only club being forced to open membership to women was the New York Athletic Club. Founded in 1868, the club contained dining rooms, bars, an indoor pool, and a block long gym. Facing legal pressure, the New York Athletic Club opened it’s membership to women in 1989 with mixed feelings on the part of members. Despite the legal and societal pressure, a few-male only clubs still exist in the U.S.

Decline of Male Space in the Home

Paralleling the decline in male space in public was the decline of male space in the domestic sphere. This perhaps was even more dramatic for men because, well, it hit so close to home. A man was once king of his castle, but in a blink of an eye he was dethroned. Here’s a brief primer on how it went down.

The Industrial Revolution: The Beginning of the End of Male Space

Before the Industrial Revolution, you could find most men working in or around the home. This was a time of self-sufficient small farmers and noble artisans. A man used his home as his place of business and, consequently, homes were designed to accommodate the needs of the dirty work of farming, blacksmithing, and leatherworking. When you work every day in dirt and grime, you can’t worry about taking off your boots so you don’t soil the rug. That just slows down the work!

Additionally, the home design luxuries we take for granted today just weren’t available to people in this agrarian society. Carpeting, wallpaper, drapes and even glass windows were items reserved for the very wealthy.

Consequently, the home had a predominately masculine vibe. Exposed beams, dirt floors, and earthen fireplaces were the norm. Tools were left here and there, guns hung above the fireplace, the sheep dog came in and out as he pleased, and a man didn’t think about wiping his feet before he came inside. He didn’t have to worry about a nagging wife getting on to him for mucking up the place because the place was already mucked up. But little did men know that the days of a male-centered abode were numbered.

By the middle of the 19th century, the Industrial Revolution was in full swing. Families moved from the country to the city, and men left home to work in the factories. Women, of course, stayed home to run the household. Thus a strict work/home dichotomy developed, with women given domain over the latter. The Cult of Domesticity, popular during this time, encouraged middle and upper class women to make the home a “haven in a heartless world” for her husband and children, a place where a man could relax and feel comforted after a long day of toiling in the trenches. Without an earthen floor and sawdust shavings everywhere, the possibility of keeping things clean and tidy became attainable, and women bought carpets, white drapes, and flower-filled vases in the name of creating a soft oasis for their husbands. But what they really had made was the type of place a woman would feel most comfortable, and men fled their doily-laden home to spend time at the bars and fraternal lodges with their boys. The home had become female space.

Victorian Era

Theodore Roosevelt’s Trophy Room at Sagamore Hill

While male space was chipped away at during the 18th century, there were some consolations. During the Victorian Era, upper and middle class homes were built with several gender specific rooms. These rooms were often divided evenly among men and women. Women had sewing, drawing, and tea rooms; men had billiards, smoking, and trophy rooms. One peculiar male room in Victorian homes was the growling room. That’s right-growling room. Apparently growling rooms were a place a man could go to be alone and “growl” when in a bad mood. (I just use the bathroom for that now. )

This period of gender balance in homes would be short lived, however, and male space would continue to shrink as women took more and more control over home life.

Suburban Living: The Elimination of Male Space

Male space in the home was exchanged for family space.

The period after WWII was filled with dramatic changes in American life. One of the most powerful changes was the migration of white, middle class families from cities to the suburbs. Large developments like Levittown provided returning vets a chance to buy a piece of the American Dream for a relatively affordable price and get started on raising a family.

The rise of suburban culture with its emphasis on creating a domestic nest, usually meant sacrificing male space for the good of the family. Home designs in the 1950s exchanged the numerous, smaller rooms of the Victorian home for fewer, larger rooms. The goal was to create more open space where families could congregate together and bond while watching the Honeymooners on TV.

With no room to call their own, men were forced to build their male sanctuaries in the most uninhabitable parts of a home. Garages, attics, and basements quickly became the designated space for men, while the women and children had free reign over the rest of the house.

Men filled these rooms with the trappings of manliness- animal heads, discarded furniture, and pictures of sports figures (or women) would adorn the room. They would use their “man caves” as a place to retreat to when the demands of work and family life felt suffocating. Here they could play cards with their friends or tinker around, working on their car, reading the paper, or doing some woodworking.

But even these undesirable areas of the home would be taken away from men. Basements and attics became game or entertainment rooms to be used mainly by children. And even the least feminine of all places-the garage-would be cleaned up and domesticated.

According to Andreas Duany, an architect and consultant for the New Urban Development, three things occurred that feminized the garage: 1) sheetrocking, 2) the emergence of the storage industry, and 3) home association requirements to keep garage doors closed.

To organize their garages, men had built their own system of workbenches and shelving. But women felt this amateur, rustic solution was still too cluttered. Everything must now be put away in sleek, manufactured cabinetry and plastic storage tubs, with all of a man’s tools and knickknacks hidden away behind a shiny facade.

Sheetrocking covered the once unexposed and manly wood frame in garages, resulting in garages that looked less like a garage and more like another room inside the house.

Finally, homeowner association guidelines that required garages to remain closed made an already inhospitable room even less desirable by shutting out the light and air.

With every room co-opted in the house by women or children, and with few bastions of manliness in the public sphere left standing to escape to, men were relegated to claiming a solitary chair as their designated male space. (Think Archie Bunker and the dad from Frasier.)

Even in a time where men and women are supposed to decide about home décor together, dimes to donuts the women makes the final call. Take the cliché joke of a couple moving in together. It’s usually the man who has to throw out his “silly man things” to make room for the more sophisticated tastes of the women. At that moment, a man realizes that there’s no hope for him to have a place of his own.

Why Male Space is Important

Alright. So you might be thinking, “What’s the big deal? Isn’t it a good thing we’ve gotten past this archaic gender segregated stuff?” Yes… and no. Don’t get me wrong. I’m all in favor of the progress we’ve made, but again, the pendulum has arguably swung too far to the other extreme, leaving men without their own space.

We often underestimate the effects our surroundings have on our psyche. Architects, interior designers, and feng shui experts understand this profound impact. Even famous feminist writer Virginia Woolf understood the importance that space can have on an individual.

In her 1928 essay A Room of One’s Own, Woolf passionately argued that the reason women hadn’t produced as many great literary works as men was because they were denied the same opportunities afforded their male counterparts. The central argument in her essay was that women needed a room of their own in a world that was predominantly male so they could be alone and connect with their true identity and creative impulses.

Eighty years later, it’s the men asking for a room of their own.

Just as male friends play an important role in giving men satisfaction and in shaping their manliness, so does male space. It’s important that men have a place where they can take off their social masks and revel in masculine energy.  For many men, the bureaucracy of corporate culture can leave them feeling powerless and emasculated. Having a “man cave” at home, a place men can deocrate as they please and do what they want in can give them a much-needed sense of control, empowerment, and of course relaxation. And spending time in the company of other men at an all-male hang out can help a man reconnect with his manliness

It seems in the past 10 years or so businesses and home designers are starting to recognize the importance of male space. Cottage industries have sprung up dedicated to designing “man caves” in homes, and many a man dreams of building a tiny house in the woods or backyard. Barbershops are coming back in a big way, and men of my generation are becoming interested in joining fraternal lodges like the Masons. Some pioneering men are even starting clubs of their own. After a period of decline, I think we’re seeing the start of a renaissance in male space. With all that’s going on, now is a better time then ever to carve out your own inner sanctum of manliness. So get to it. Your man cave awaits.

{ 114 comments… read them below or add one }

101 Jake March 3, 2010 at 9:51 pm

Yes Mike…because doing whatever you want WITHOUT CONSIDERATION for your wife is such a good thing…
I guess what I’m saying is, the man-cave, or whatever you want to call it, can be a great space for men who want it. But if the man has his private space, its only fair for the wife to have her space as well. And if your reason for a man-cave is because you need a place that you have control over, versus because you want some privacy, thats a problem. A better solution would be to grow a pair and start taking some control over the entire house. Don’t let your wife decorate it if you don’t like it, just like she should have veto power over your manly decorating schemes. Find something you can both agree on, and if you still feel a need for privacy, give each of you a “cave”.

102 kevin March 12, 2010 at 6:51 pm

Why are so many women on here getting there panties in a wad. Hello its a male website. If you dont like it dont come to it . Go watch oprah or whatever . Men dont go to redbook or whatever and complain about what women write there . Or they shouldn’t . If they do they need to stay there .

103 Shane March 14, 2010 at 4:17 pm

I encourage you to understand the battle is not against women who have somehow stolen our space, but it is against the part in ourselves that gave it up. If your goal of attaining or maintaining man space is to have a place to get away from your family, then you don’t deserve it. Man space should be a place to build tangible things and your character, not to get away from your family.

104 Bee April 9, 2010 at 10:07 am

I quite enjoyed reading the article but I think that some of the content is a little skewed. What you describe in your history of man spaces are just gender stereotypes. As we all know these stereotypes can be sometimes informative but not true for everyone and painting everyone of the same gender with the same stroke is not productive. From the article and a lot of the comments there is way too much association of stereotypical behaviours with a gender and assuming they are the sole owners of the behaviours e.g swearing is a manly thing and cleaning is a woman’s thing. I have never found this behaviour productive. And I think it never adds any real value to a discussion.

Some of the descriptions of men on this blog reminds of the scene in Disney’s Mulan when Mulan tries to talk like a man ‘Uhh… I mean, uh, sorry you had to see that, but you know how it is when you get those, uh, manly urges, and you just gotta kill somethin’… fix things, uh, cook outdoors…’ Entirely laughable and ridiculously stereotypical.

The whole women’s gym thing is an example of positive discrimination – where a group that was previously disadvantaged is now being intentionally being protected and supported. This is why the arguments don’t normally go through the courts. As a woman I don’t think a lot of this positive discrimination works very well. It seems to only build an ‘us vs. them’ mentality – which is quite evident on some of the comments on this blog.

But that aside, I think there is a lot of merit in the argument that everyone needs their own space – men and women. We all need some time and space to have things the way we like it with no one dictating what our space should be like. It’s some alone time to wind down, think and relax. I think we can all agree that everyone regardless of gender deserves that.

@Andrew Raker ‘Men need a place to go and to call their own, without the hypocrisy and judgement of women’ – I do hope you mean some women and not all. Because your latter statement that you are not blaming women would be contradictory otherwise :)

105 Matt April 10, 2010 at 11:17 pm

I agree with this article in many if not most of the points it has made. What I would like to add is that it’s very possible to create your man space in a purely metaphysical manner. What I mean is this: Regardless of your surroundings and the presence of women, treat it was if it were your own man space. Say what you mean to say, do what you would do in your man space. Don’t let anyone else tell you what you can and cannot do. After all, this is your space now.

I often bring my own space with me. My presence is my own space. As long as you assert this and do not waver, you will be fine. Not only will you find that making jokes and saying things to other men that you wouldn’t normally do in the presence of women brings you confidence and satisfaction, but it also instils respect for you from the people around you. As long as you don’t go overboard, you will be fine.

106 Damian Salandy April 18, 2010 at 10:20 am

THANK YOU…THANK YOU…THANK YOU!!!!

It’s nice to read a piece regarding masculine spaces without the word “silly” being used to describe our needing our own space, coming into play!

107 Mark July 21, 2010 at 8:47 pm

Yeah it seems us fella are getting pushed farther and farther away from manhood, its time to take a stand! But you go first,my old lady would kill LOL.

108 Kari November 30, 2012 at 8:24 pm

I agree with this article in that men deserve and need space in which to decorate/congregate/socialize/relaxe/whatever. I also believe that women deserve this space. Unfortunately, women historically have not been given space at all. If a space was allowed it was a devalued common space in which they are expected to work while they occupy the space (i.e. the kitchen, a home full of children and chores, etc.). An issue I had with this article–and again: not with the concept of gendered spaces–is the inherent power that men have access to within their spaces. By not allowing Women admission to social clubs and to after-dinner political conversations, they were effectively barred from accessing to power through association and power through knowledge–power that men then perpetually kept for themselves and benefited from. Women were not allowed to be in the space where decisions were made, let alone have a hand in making the decisions, or be around to understand the process of how those in power came to the conclusions they came to. Until women do have equal access to power, and decisions are not being made in male-only areas, or amongst solely men, male-only areas are still a threat to equality (which we haven’t attained yet, in case you were wondering).

109 Rei May 6, 2013 at 11:19 pm

This is pretty interesting. I think it would be nice if everybody could have some space and time to just kind of do what they do, especially if it’s something productive, whether it’s woodwork, computer programming, meditation, etc. Everybody needs their own space, and nobody needs all of it. I think a lot of people these days are also living in homes that don’t have that much space to begin with, so it’s hard to divide space, especially when people have children. I think that’s part of what makes men surrender the whole house. It’s a small house. If he claims a bunch of space for himself, where is everybody going to live?

I mean, this is all cool, having special rooms, special things in the yard, maybe one for each gender. A man cave and a lady cave where she can be herself and not just a mom or a wife all the time. A lot of those things, though, weren’t really luxuries for every person. Gender caves sound like fun, but unless you are making really good money, you’re probably better off just taking more charge in the space you have, or maybe the time that you have, however it can be done. “This is my man hour.” “This is my woman hour.” something like that. I don’t know.

110 kaysie September 14, 2013 at 8:01 pm

I really enjoyed this article, and I agree in many ways. I think a previous commenter makes a good point that the only downside with reinstituting more man-only clubs is the tendency for politics, business and power to stay centered in those clubs, leaving women disadvantaged in the co-ed work world. One of the challenges of all male space is men bro-ing out, and rather than celebrating their bonds and positive masculine qualities, just making bad jokes about women and drinking beer and celebrating their vices.
Which brings me to the point I’d like to make, that for the most part men have not lost their man caves because women threw them out, but because men don’t do many man things anymore. Really, what is considered manly? Drinking beer and watching sports for most of the men I grew up with. Very few learned how to use tools, hunt, test their strength, be heroic, treat women kindly etc. In my 20′s, living in co-ed shared housing or with women, I became the “man around the house,” who would build shelving or fix things because none of the men we knew had any skills to do anything. I would ask to borrow tools I didn’t have, or help with doing the brakes on my car- all of the men I knew had no tools and no skills. Not their fault- our entire culture has moved away from taking pride in doing things with our hands, in building, in strength, in doing things that might be dangerous. There is a cultural movement that encourages white collar jobs and the metrosexualization of men. Might I guess those plastic tubs in the garage aren’t because wifey was complaining, but because the man no longer had the ability to work on the car (without the $20,000 computer to do diagnostics) or the knowledge (because so many high schools don’t have shop classes, and so many fathers no longer have time or knowledge to do man things with their sons).
I would love the revival of man space… and sometimes I would like to be welcomed into that space to do some masculine things, because as a woman I still want to be able to change my oil and hunt my dinner. (That doesn’t mean I want to put doilies in your garage.) I too would like more man things in the world- but real ones, not just guys bro-ing out, making fun of women, drinking beer and watching a game on TV.
If grown men were still doing real man things- like playing sports themselves instead of watching them, fixing cars, building stuff- maybe women would be more welcoming to man-spaces.
Not to blame you, men, it’s a whole crazy societal thing we have going on. Good luck in creating some space for yourselves, and when you do- please do something wonderful with it, that makes you a better man.

111 Capt'n Torr September 21, 2013 at 6:43 pm

Well, blow me down!
A fine article, indeed. This page is one of individual thoughts, considering one and all. some people here comment for, and against said ideas, and fairly so.

nowhere dose the article say that these are all “facts”, that the content is unquestionable and that all men in the whole world agree and think like this.

I personally agree with the article.
Men Need Space To Think.

112 Tim September 27, 2013 at 8:36 pm

Yes, “male space” – like a truly fantastic website where we can freely discuss the ideals of manliness, learn from other men, and not be belittled by any negativity…wait…where did those negative comments come from with names that sound female. There are women here too? Proof that this article is true and that we have lost all sacred space. Thank you for the great points in the article. And the articles since.

113 Andreas Hagnos December 8, 2013 at 2:24 am

As a young man I feel this need desperately. I will not go into the PC bullshit. Everyone needs space and when one is deprived of it, they may suffer terribly and even act completely out of character in an attempt to re-balance in some way.

I’m 24 and in a two year relationship. So far it’s looking like I’m going to lose my “life-partner” because she doesn’t understand that space isn’t just sleep or rest — it’s the ability to be alone with oneself in peace. I have not had “peace” in this way since we’ve been together. All she ever sees of me are my weaknesses, weaknesses which would primarily be dealt and processed within a sacred space of some sort. For the past two years I’ve had either my coworkers in my face, or my wife telling me how effeminate I am.

And then she wonders why I don’t want to have sex with her/can’t perform. :/

114 Kylaila March 29, 2014 at 1:37 pm

I don’t see any reason to be upset with either side – it is a matter of fact that “men space” is being lost for reasons stated neutrally in the article.
It is also a matter of fact that in the attempt to achieve gender equality, men are at a certain disadvantage, because they’re “generally better off” and that as a result, reasonable request are turned off.

As always, if you need something for yourself, you need to fight for it. And rightly so, everyone needs space for themselves – male probably even more so, because it’s evolutionarily engrained to have more free space for oneself as opposed to women taking care of children etc.
As much as we hate stereotypes, we need to remind ourselves of three things:

1. They came into being for a reason
2. They don’t say jack shit for an individual
3. They are not all there is to a person.
Stereotypes are the result of breaking something down to a few striking features, they alone can’t picture a person as a whole.

Thank you for this article, people need to establish their space right off the bat or they’ll struggle even more when they want to get it later on.
Not to mention that having your own space will ultimately benefit everyone involved.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

Site Meter