War is a violent and bloody business, but it’s rarely a no-holds barred free-for-all. Instead, codes of conduct that determine what is and isn’t honorable behavior on the battlefield have existed since ancient times.
My guest today explored these various codes in a book she wrote during the decade she spent teaching at the United States Naval Academy. Her name is Shannon French, she’s a professor of ethics and philosophy, and her book is The Code of the Warrior: Exploring Warrior Values Past and Present. Shannon and I begin our conversation with the pointed questions she used to pose to the cadets she taught as to how being a warrior was different than being a killer or murderer, and when killing is and isn’t ethical. She then explains how the warrior codes which developed all around the world arose organically from warriors themselves for their own protection, and how these codes are more about identity than rules. Shannon and I then take a tour of warrior codes across time and culture, starting with the code in Homer’s Iliad, and then moving into the strengths and weaknesses of the Stoic philosophy which undergirded the code of the Romans. From there we unpack the code of the medieval knights of Arthurian legend, what American Indians can teach soldiers about the need to make clear transitions between the homefront and the warfront, and how the Bushido code of the samurais sought to balance the influence of four different religions. We end our conversation with the role warrior codes play today in an age of increasingly technologized combat.
If reading this in an email, click the title of the post to listen to the show.
- Defining the term “warrior” as opposed to soldier, fighter, killer, murderer, etc.
- Why is it important to define a warrior’s code?
- Why are these codes sometimes intentionally vague?
- What Homer’s famous works can teach us about warrior codes
- Roman views on military ethics
- The Stoic view of a virtuous warrior
- The warrior code found in the Arthurian tales of The Knights of the Round Table
- How the Samurai Bushido code came to be
Resources/People/Articles Mentioned in Podcast
- Why You Need a Philosophical Survival Kit
- The Warrior’s Manifesto
- The Way of the Monastic Warrior
- The Way of the Stoic Warrior
- The Warrior Ethos
- The Warrior Archetype
- AoM series of Sioux guides
- Aristotle’s Wisdom on Living the Good Life
- Hector and Achilles: Two Paths to Manliness
- What Homer’s Odyssey Can Teach Us Today
- How Soldiers Die in Battle
- What Plato’s Republic Has to Say About Being a Man
- How to Think Like a Roman Emperor
- The Fall of the Roman Republic
- Lessons From the Roman Art of War
- Thoughts of a Philosophical Fighter Pilot
- Le Morte Darthur
- Achilles in Vietnam
- The Bushido Code
- Everything You Know About Ninjas is Wrong
Connect With Shannon
Listen to the Podcast! (And don’t forget to leave us a review!)
Listen ad-free on Stitcher Premium; get a free month when you use code “manliness” at checkout.
Read the Transcript